Cub Cadet vs Craftsman Riding Mower: Which is Better?

In the verdant world of lawn care, the quest for the perfect riding mower can feel like navigating a labyrinth of grassy knolls and technical specifications. With an overwhelming array of options, two names stand out in the garden shed spotlight: Cub Cadet and Craftsman. These titans of turf management have been vying for the hearts and lawns of homeowners for years, each boasting a lineage of reliability and innovation. But here’s a surprising statistic: despite the fierce competition, both brands are branches of the same tree, MTD, making the choice between them even more intriguing.

As you stand at the crossroads of decision, pondering whether the Cub Cadet’s precision or Craftsman’s durability will best suit your sward, this blog post promises to be your compass. We’ll delve into the nitty-gritty of Cub Cadet vs Craftsman riding mowers, comparing everything from horsepower to comfort, price to performance, and everything in between. By the end of this journey, you’ll be equipped with the knowledge to choose not just a mower, but a partner in your quest for the perfect lawn.

Keynote: Cub Cadet vs Craftsman Riding Mower

Cub Cadet excels in precision and advanced features for efficient lawn care, while Craftsman provides durability and value, ideal for budget-conscious homeowners. Choose Cub Cadet for technological superiority or Craftsman for reliable performance, depending on your lawn needs. Both brands ensure a satisfying mowing experience.

Cutting Performance: A Blade-by-Blade Breakdown

When it comes to manicuring your lawn to perfection, the cutting performance of your riding mower takes center stage. Cub Cadet and Craftsman, both powerhouses in the lawn care arena, offer a range of options designed to meet the needs of different landscapes.

Let’s dissect their offerings, focusing on cutting width, height adjustment range, blade types, and the all-important mulching options. Additionally, we’ll explore how each brand fares across various terrains, including challenging hills and those pesky tight spots.

Cutting Width and Height Adjustment

  • Cub Cadet: Known for its versatility, Cub Cadet offers mowers with cutting widths that typically range from 42 inches to 54 inches, catering to both modest suburban lots and more expansive estates. The height adjustment feature is user-friendly, with models like the XT1 LT50 providing up to 12 positions, allowing for precision cutting from 1 inch to 4 inches. This flexibility ensures that regardless of the season or grass type, your lawn can be cut to the perfect height.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman riding mowers, such as the T260, boast similar cutting widths, also ranging from 42 inches to 54 inches. Their height adjustment lever is equally accessible, offering multiple positions for cutting heights that ensure your lawn looks exactly how you want it. The Craftsman mowers are designed with ease in mind, making adjustments simple and straightforward for users of all experience levels.

Blade Types and Mulching Options

  • Cub Cadet: Blades on Cub Cadet mowers are engineered for durability and performance. Many models come equipped with standard mulching blades that finely chop grass clippings and return them to the lawn as natural fertilizer. Optional accessories, like the mulching kits available for the XT series, enhance this capability, promoting a healthier lawn with less effort.
  • Craftsman: Similarly, Craftsman mowers feature high-performance blades that cut with precision. The brand offers mulching blades that can be added to most models, providing the same eco-friendly option of feeding your lawn with the nutrients from the grass clippings. The Craftsman T260, for example, not only comes with a robust stamped 50” deck but also supports mulching, ensuring that users have the option to mulch if they choose.

Cut Quality Across Various Terrains

  • Cub Cadet: Cub Cadet riding mowers shine on varied terrains, including hills and tight spots. The XT1 LT50, with its tight turn radius and responsive handling, maneuvers easily around obstacles and maintains a consistent cut on slopes, thanks to its balanced weight distribution and traction control. The quality of the cut remains high even in challenging conditions, leaving a clean, even appearance.
  • Craftsman: The Craftsman T260’s super tight turn radius is a game-changer for navigating around garden beds, trees, and other tight spots. Its performance on hills is commendable, with enough power and stability to tackle inclines without sacrificing cut quality. The Craftsman mowers are designed to handle the contours and challenges of your lawn, ensuring a uniform cut across every inch.

Build Construction and Durability: The Foundation of a Lasting Lawn Legacy

The resilience of a riding mower is pivotal to its lifespan and performance. Both Cub Cadet and Craftsman have built reputations on the strength of their construction and the durability of their machines.

Let’s delve into the materials and craftsmanship that define these brands, examining the frame, body, and deck materials, including the thickness and overall construction quality. Additionally, we’ll present a comparative overview of warranties and longevity expectations, offering a snapshot of manufacturer confidence in these robust machines.

Frame, Body, and Deck Materials

Cub Cadet and Craftsman riding mowers are designed with durability at their core, featuring robust frames and decks that stand up to the rigors of lawn maintenance. Here’s how they stack up in terms of construction:

  1. Frame Construction: Both brands utilize heavy-duty steel frames, but the thickness and reinforcement strategies may vary between models. Cub Cadet often employs fully welded steel frames in its XT series, providing a sturdy foundation that’s built to last. Craftsman, similarly, uses reinforced steel frames, especially in its Pro Series, ensuring strength and durability over many years of use.
  2. Body Materials: The body of the mowers, including the hood and fenders, are typically made from high-impact polymers or steel. Cub Cadet models feature polymer bodies designed to resist corrosion and fading, while Craftsman mowers often use a combination of steel and polymer for resilience and longevity.
  3. Deck Construction: The cutting deck is critical to mower performance. Cub Cadet decks are made from stamped or fabricated steel, offering a balance between durability and cutting efficiency. Craftsman mowers also boast steel decks, with some models featuring a stamped design for optimal airflow and consistent cutting.

Warranties and Longevity Expectations

To provide a clear overview of manufacturer confidence and expected durability, the following table compares the warranties and longevity expectations for Cub Cadet and Craftsman models:

FeatureCub CadetCraftsman
Warranty Length3-Year Limited Warranty with a 5-Year Chassis and Front Axle2-Year Limited Warranty, with some models offering up to a 3-Year Limited Warranty
Deck Warranty3-Year Limited Warranty, with some models offering a Lifetime Deck Shell Warranty2-Year Limited Warranty, with some models offering a 5-Year Deck Warranty
Longevity Expectations10+ years with proper maintenance8+ years with proper maintenance
Material Thickness12-gauge to 10-gauge steel decks13-gauge to 11-gauge steel decks
Construction QualityHigh-quality welds and robust construction for maximum durabilitySolid construction with reinforced areas prone to stress

Comfort and Convenience: The Key to Enjoyable Lawn Maintenance

When it comes to selecting the right riding mower, the aspects of comfort and convenience can’t be overlooked. After all, maintaining your lawn should be a pleasure, not a chore. Both Cub Cadet and Craftsman understand this, designing their mowers with features that enhance the user experience.

Let’s explore how seat design, steering, control accessibility, and maneuverability contribute to making lawn maintenance more enjoyable and less taxing.

Seat Design: Ensuring Comfort in Every Ride

  • Cub Cadet: Cub Cadet mowers are renowned for their comfortable seating. With high-back seats that often include ample padding and adjustable positions, they ensure comfort during extended use. Models like the XT1 Enduro Series go a step further, offering seats with enhanced ergonomics and even armrests in higher-end models, making long mowing sessions feel like a breeze.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman doesn’t lag in comfort either. Their riding mowers feature adjustable seats with varying degrees of padding to support prolonged periods of mowing. The Craftsman T260, for instance, boasts a high-back seat with added cushioning and the ability to adjust for different operator heights, ensuring a comfortable ride regardless of the lawn size.

Steering and Control Accessibility: The Ease of Navigation

  • Cub Cadet: The steering and control system on Cub Cadet mowers are designed for ease of use and accessibility. Many models feature soft-touch steering wheels and ergonomically placed controls, minimizing operator fatigue. The addition of cruise control in models like the XT1 LT50 allows for consistent speed over large areas, reducing the need for constant speed adjustments.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman riding mowers also prioritize steering ease and control accessibility. With features like a tight turning radius and intuitive control placement, navigating around obstacles and tight spaces becomes less cumbersome. Models equipped with cruise control, such as the Craftsman T260, offer the same advantage of maintaining a steady pace, making it easier to tackle large lawns efficiently.

The Importance of Maneuverability

Considering the average American lawn size ranges from 1/4 to 1/2 acre, maneuverability is a critical factor in choosing a riding mower. Both Cub Cadet and Craftsman have engineered their mowers to excel in this area:

  1. Turning Radius: Cub Cadet’s XT series, known for its tight turn radius, allows for precise navigation around garden beds, trees, and other common yard obstacles. Similarly, Craftsman’s mowers, especially those with the “Turn Tight” technology, boast a turning radius as low as 5 inches, making them ideal for intricate landscaping.
  2. Cruise Control and Steering: The presence of cruise control in both brands’ models speaks to their understanding of user needs, especially when covering larger areas. This feature, combined with responsive steering, ensures that operators can maintain a beautiful lawn with less effort and more comfort.

Additional Features: Beyond the Basics

In the realm of riding mowers, Cub Cadet and Craftsman don’t just stop at cutting grass. They push the envelope with additional features that enhance functionality, convenience, and the overall mowing experience. From headlights to cargo beds and a suite of available attachments, these brands offer innovations that cater to a wide range of lawn care needs.

Let’s dive into the unique features and technological integrations that set these mowers apart.

Headlights, Cargo Beds, and Attachments

Cub Cadet: Cub Cadet mowers come equipped with features designed to extend usability and versatility. For instance:

  1. Headlights are standard on many models, like the XT1 Enduro Series, allowing for mowing in low-light conditions.
  2. Cargo Beds are available on select models, such as the XT Enduro Series, transforming the mower into a multi-functional yard vehicle.
  3. Attachments: Cub Cadet offers a wide array of attachments, including snow blowers, tow-behind sprayers, and baggers, enhancing the mower’s utility across all seasons.

Craftsman: Craftsman also offers a range of features aimed at improving user experience and versatility:

  1. Headlights for early morning or late evening tasks are standard on models like the T260.
  2. Cargo Beds are not as commonly found on Craftsman mowers as on Cub Cadet models, but the brand compensates with a robust selection of towable accessories and attachments.
  3. Attachments: From mulching kits to snow attachments, Craftsman provides options to ensure your mower is a year-round tool.

Dashboard Features and Technology Integration

The integration of technology into riding mowers has significantly enhanced the user experience, with both Cub Cadet and Craftsman incorporating advanced dashboard features in their models. Here’s a comparison of what you might find:

Cub Cadet:

  1. Smartphone Connectivity: Select models offer Bluetooth connectivity, allowing users to monitor maintenance schedules and mower performance via a dedicated app.
  2. Digital Dashboards: Featured in the XT Enduro Series, providing real-time feedback on fuel levels, battery health, and maintenance reminders.


  1. Simple, User-Friendly Dashboards: While Craftsman mowers may not boast as many high-tech dashboard features as Cub Cadet, they focus on ease of use with clear, intuitive controls.
  2. Maintenance Alerts: Some models include basic digital displays for tracking maintenance intervals and mower diagnostics.

Price and Value Comparison: Cub Cadet vs. Craftsman

When investing in a riding mower, understanding the balance between cost and features is crucial. Cub Cadet and Craftsman offer a spectrum of models catering to different budgets and needs, making a direct comparison valuable for potential buyers.

Let’s explore the MSRP across various models from both brands and delve into the price/feature ratio to determine which offers the best value for your investment.

MSRP Across Models

Both Cub Cadet and Craftsman have entry-level, mid-range, and high-end models, each with its own set of features and capabilities. Here’s a general overview of the price range you can expect:

  • Cub Cadet: Prices for Cub Cadet riding mowers start at around $1,500 for basic models like the LT42, which offers a 42-inch cutting deck and a reliable engine suitable for smaller lawns. Mid-range models such as the XT1 LT50 are priced around $2,000, providing a larger deck and additional features like Bluetooth connectivity. High-end models, including the XT2 GX54 D, can reach upwards of $3,500, boasting larger engines, advanced cutting systems, and more luxurious comfort features.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman’s lineup begins with models like the T110, priced around $1,400, featuring a 42-inch cutting deck and a solid engine for small to medium-sized lawns. The mid-tier T260, with a price tag of approximately $2,300, offers a larger cutting deck, tighter turn radius, and enhanced comfort features. For around $3,000, top-tier models like the T310 provide premium engines, wider cutting decks, and additional durability features.

Price/Feature Ratio

To better understand what you’re getting for your money, let’s compare the price/feature ratio of both brands:

FeatureCub Cadet (Example Model)Craftsman (Example Model)Price
Entry-Level42-inch deck, basic engine42-inch deck, basic engineCub Cadet: ~$1,500 Craftsman: ~$1,400
Mid-Range50-inch deck, Bluetooth connectivity50-inch deck, tight turn radiusCub Cadet: ~$2,000
Craftsman: ~$2,300
High-End54-inch deck, advanced cutting system54-inch deck, premium engineCub Cadet: ~$3,500
Craftsman: ~$3,000

Industry Expert Quote

An industry expert, when asked about the value proposition of Cub Cadet and Craftsman, stated:

“Cub Cadet and Craftsman both offer exceptional value in their respective segments. Cub Cadet tends to focus more on technological integration and advanced features, which justifies its slightly higher price point in certain models.

Craftsman, on the other hand, offers solid, reliable performance with a focus on durability and ease of use, often at a more accessible price point. The best value depends on the homeowner’s specific needs and how they prioritize features like cutting performance, comfort, and technology.”

Maintenance Requirements: Keeping Your Mower Running Smoothly

Regular maintenance is the key to ensuring your riding mower operates efficiently for years to come. Both Cub Cadet and Craftsman design their mowers with maintenance in mind, but there are differences in ease of access, cost, and availability of replacement parts.

Understanding these aspects can help you gauge the long-term ownership costs and decide which brand aligns with your maintenance capabilities and budget.

Ease of Access for Regular Service

  • Cub Cadet: Cub Cadet mowers are designed with the user’s maintenance needs in mind. Many models feature easily accessible oil filters, spark plugs, and air filters, allowing for straightforward service without the need for specialized tools. The XT Enduro Series, for example, has a clear design focus on maintenance, with components strategically placed for easy access.
  • Craftsman: Similarly, Craftsman riding mowers offer user-friendly maintenance features. Their mowers come with tool-less access to key maintenance points, making routine checks and replacements less of a hassle. The T260 model emphasizes this approach, with a design that simplifies the process of accessing the deck, changing oil, or replacing filters.

Cost and Availability of Replacement Parts

The cost and availability of replacement parts are crucial factors in the long-term value of your mower. Here’s how Cub Cadet and Craftsman stack up:

  • Cub Cadet: Replacement parts for Cub Cadet mowers are readily available through a wide network of dealers and online retailers. While some proprietary parts may carry a premium price tag, the brand’s commitment to durability means less frequent replacements. Additionally, Cub Cadet offers a range of universal maintenance parts that can help keep costs down.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman benefits from a broad distribution network, thanks to its presence in major retailers and online platforms. This accessibility often translates to competitive pricing and availability for replacement parts. Craftsman’s use of some standardized parts across models can further ease the cost of maintenance.

Long-Term Ownership Costs

Considering the ease of maintenance and the cost of replacement parts, both Cub Cadet and Craftsman offer compelling options for homeowners. However, the long-term ownership costs can vary based on the model and how intensively the mower is used. Here are a few considerations:

  1. Warranty Coverage: Both brands offer warranties that can mitigate some of the early costs of replacement parts. Reviewing the warranty details can provide insights into potential savings during the initial years of ownership.
  2. Durability: The inherent durability of the mower can impact long-term costs. Models known for their robust construction and reliability may require fewer repairs and replacements over time, affecting overall cost of ownership.
  3. Maintenance Frequency: The specific maintenance requirements and recommended service intervals also play a role. Models that demand less frequent service or use more widely available and affordable parts can offer better long-term value.

Verdict: Cub Cadet vs. Craftsman Riding Mower Showdown

After a comprehensive analysis of cut quality, features, budget considerations, and suitability for specific lawn types, it’s time to draw conclusions about which brand—Cub Cadet or Craftsman—stands out in each category. This verdict aims to guide you in choosing the riding mower that best fits your needs, preferences, and lawn characteristics.

Best Brand for Cut Quality

Cub Cadet takes the lead in cut quality. With its range of models featuring advanced cutting systems, precision engineering, and a variety of deck sizes, Cub Cadet mowers provide a consistently clean and even cut. The brand’s attention to blade design and deck construction ensures exceptional performance across a wide range of grass types and conditions. For homeowners prioritizing a pristine lawn appearance, Cub Cadet is the superior choice.

Best Brand for Features

When it comes to additional functionalities that enhance usability and convenience, Cub Cadet again edges out Craftsman. Cub Cadet’s integration of technology, such as Bluetooth connectivity and smart dashboards, along with comfort-focused features like adjustable high-back seats and ergonomic controls, positions it as the leader in this category. The brand’s wide array of attachments and accessories further extends its usability beyond mere mowing, offering a versatile, all-season tool.

Best Brand for Budget Buyers

Craftsman is the go-to brand for budget-conscious buyers. With a slightly lower entry price for its base models and a reputation for solid, no-frills performance, Craftsman offers excellent value. The brand’s riding mowers are durable, reliable, and backed by a wide availability of affordable replacement parts. Considering both initial purchase price and long-term maintenance costs, Craftsman provides a cost-effective solution without compromising on quality.

Best Brand for Specific Lawn Types

For lawns with hills or numerous obstacles, Cub Cadet stands out due to its superior maneuverability and performance in challenging terrains. Models with tight turn radii and responsive steering make navigating around obstacles a breeze, while the brand’s powerful engines and traction control systems handle slopes with ease. Cub Cadet’s design considerations for ease of use and comfort also make it the preferred choice for maintaining complex landscapes.

Overall Recommendation

While both Cub Cadet and Craftsman offer compelling options, the best brand for you depends on your specific needs:

  1. For homeowners prioritizing cut quality and advanced features, Cub Cadet offers a range of models that excel in precision, technology integration, and versatility.
  2. For budget-conscious buyers and those seeking solid performance with lower long-term costs, Craftsman provides durable, reliable mowers that deliver excellent value.
  3. For those with challenging lawn types, including hilly terrains or landscapes filled with obstacles, Cub Cadet’s maneuverability and performance capabilities make it the superior choice.

Final Thoughts

The choice between Cub Cadet and Craftsman transcends mere brand loyalty; it reflects a gardener’s priorities, be it technological sophistication, budget considerations, or specific landscaping challenges. This comparison not only highlights the strengths and nuances of each brand but also mirrors the evolving landscape of home gardening, where efficiency, comfort, and cost-effectiveness become the pillars of modern lawn maintenance.

Choosing between Cub Cadet and Craftsman is more than selecting a riding mower; it’s about crafting a personal relationship with your lawn. As you ponder this decision, consider not just the blades that cut the grass but the joy and satisfaction derived from each pass over your green canvas. In the end, the best mower is not just about the cut it delivers but the experience it offers, turning every mowing session into a journey of discovery and fulfillment.

Craftsman vs Cub Cadet Lawn Tractor (FAQs)

Is Craftsman a good brand of riding lawn mower?

Craftsman is considered a reliable brand for riding lawn mowers, known for their durability and performance across various lawn sizes.

Does Cub Cadet make a good riding mower?

Cub Cadet is highly regarded for producing quality riding mowers, offering advanced features and efficient performance for both residential and commercial use.

What is the life expectancy of a Craftsman riding lawn mower?

The life expectancy of a Craftsman riding lawn mower, with proper maintenance, is typically around 10 to 15 years.

Is Craftsman the same as Cub Cadet?

Craftsman and Cub Cadet are distinct brands; both are manufactured by MTD Products Inc., but they offer different models and features tailored to various needs.

Should I buy cub cadet for my three acres lawns?

For managing three acres of lawn, a Cub Cadet riding mower, especially models designed for larger areas, would be a suitable and efficient choice due to their power and cutting width.

Who Owned Cub Cadet Before MTD Acquired It?

Before MTD Products Inc. acquired it, Cub Cadet was originally owned by International Harvester, introduced as a line of garden tractors in 1961.

Which is better, a Craftsman or a John Deere riding mower?

Comparing Craftsman and John Deere riding mowers, John Deere is often perceived as offering higher quality and durability, but Craftsman provides good value and is competitive in terms of features and price.

Which is better craftsman or Husqvarna riding mower?

When choosing between Craftsman and Husqvarna riding mowers, Husqvarna tends to offer more powerful and feature-rich models, making it a better choice for more demanding lawn care tasks, but Craftsman mowers are known for their reliability and value.

Can Cub Cadet riding mowers be equipped with Kohler engines for enhanced performance?

Yes, many Cub Cadet riding mowers come equipped with Kohler engines, known for their reliability and high horsepower (hp), providing robust performance for demanding lawn care tasks.

What advantage does a hydrostatic transmission offer in a riding lawn mower?

A hydrostatic transmission in a riding lawn mower offers smoother operation and easier speed adjustments compared to manual transmissions, enhancing maneuverability and ease of use during lawn mowing.

Is it possible to find a push mower at Sears that includes a hose attachment for easy cleaning?

Yes, Sears offers a variety of push mowers that include a hose attachment feature, allowing for easy cleaning of the mower’s undercarriage by connecting a garden hose directly to the mower.

How does the fuel efficiency of a riding mower with a 1-gallon tank compare to other models?

Riding mowers with a 1-gallon fuel tank are typically more fuel-efficient for small to medium-sized lawns, reducing the need for frequent refueling and offering a balance between capacity and efficiency.

Leave a Comment