Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports – 10 Comparison & Buying Guide

Rainy season is full of fun and joy, but when it ends, all that’s left are dirt, leaves, and muck. It is never good to see filth on the roads and in the gutters.

Without durable gutter guards, you’ll encounter numerous problems. Too much tension may lead to insomnia.

The best gutter guards come into play to prevent this. Consumer reports on best gutter guards may assist you in choosing the best option.

You can overcome all the confusion and frustration by following the instructions in this article. The top ten best gutter guards consumer reports are based on deep research, market observations, and consumer experiences.

“The Nifty House earns a commission from the links below at no additional cost to you.”

Top 10 Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports [Expert Reviews & Buying Guide 2024]

1. Raptor Gutter Guard Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh

  • Type: Micromesh
  • Material: Stainless Steel & Aluminum
  • Shape: Rectangular
  • Installation Method: Screw-In & self-install
  • Total Pieces: ‎12
  • Weight: ‎10.93 pounds
  • Warranty: 25 years
71VsNTXTQiL. AC SL1100

Raptor Gutter Guard Reviews

Raptor Gutter Guard is effective at blocking everything from small particles to pine needles, leaves, insects, and pests.

Micro-mesh covers easily slip under roof shingles, while screws fasten the outer edge to the gutter for added security. The kit includes rust-proof screws and a magnetic hex driver.

Raptor gutter covers come in 48-foot long, 5-foot-wide strips. It is quite easy to install on gutters that are 6″ to 7″ in length –simply lift the roof panel and follow the instructions. The manual will show you every step with pictures. If you would like to learn more about the best gutter guards for steep roofs, read this article.

It comes with a 25-year warranty as well as an experienced US-based support team. That shows the manufacturers’ confidence and trust in the product. With this product, leaks are not an issue. Additionally, they provide you with a free cleaning brush so you can maintain your gutter guards like brand new.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for pine needles


  • Easy installation with user-friendly manual
  • High-quality materials that don’t rust or warp
  • Won’t void roof warranties
  • Multiple mounting options available
  • Easily removable for cleaning
  • Blocks even the smallest debris
  • Comes with all necessary hardware


  • May collapse in heavy snowfall
  • Water may overflow if surface is blocked
  • Cutting can be difficult
  • Slightly higher cost compared to other gutter guards

2. FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System

  • Type: Micromesh
  • Material: ‎Aluminum
  • Shape: Rectangular
  • Installation Method: Screw Hangars
  • Total Pieces: ‎27
  • Weight: ‎10 pounds
  • Warranty: 30 years
61dwr59THGL. AC SL1000

Flexxpoint Gutter Cover Reviews

Aluminum or stainless steel is used in the Flexpoint Gutter Guard, which makes it durable and resistant to corrosion and rust.

The product is available in eight different types and sizes, so compatibility is not an issue. It will not damage your roof, cost you more, or void your warranty, as it comes in four-foot-long sections that are relatively easy to install. The 3-point design acts as a barrier to overflowing water, protecting your landscape and foundation.

You can choose a color that matches your home with this system. There are four color options available: white, black, brown, and matte.

It allows the water to flow freely as it removes any impurity or compound that might cause the water to stagnate or obstruct its flow. You can use it without any problems for about 30 years.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for snow and ice


  • Durable fasteners
  • Does not void roof warranty
  • Cannot be seen from the ground
  • Easy to handle with four-foot sections
  • Made in the USA
  • Affordable price
  • Available in a variety of colors and sizes


  • The holes may contain ash tree seeds
  • Not suitable for old gutters
  • Doesn’t work well in cold climates

3. Amerimax Home Products Lock-In Gutter Guard

  • Type: Mesh
  • Material: ‎Steel
  • Shape: Linear
  • Installation Method: Lock-In
  • Total Pieces: 25
  • Weight: 11.5 pounds
  • Warranty: 10 years
91iiEoZXpWL. AC SL1500

Amerimax Home Products Gutter Guard Review

You won’t have to worry about debris getting inside your gutter with this gutter guard. With a metal mesh pattern, it is made of powder-coated steel and is compatible with a wide range of gutters. Installing the gutter guard is as simple as locking it to the front lip of the gutter.

Its construction is not only of excellent quality, but it is also easy to install. Just snap the pieces into place. Additionally, we appreciate that they are available in multiple widths, making them ideal for most gutter sizes.

The screen was easy to cut, and the mounting options were flexible. It worked well at keeping debris out, but smaller bits did get in. The cut mesh on the brackets caused a problem when removing the guard.

This gutter guard is perfect for those who want a quality gutter guard but don’t want to spend a small fortune on higher-priced products.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for heavy rain


  • Can withstand water pressure and debris
  • Maintains its original shape
  • Allows water to flow freely and consistently
  • Easily installed
  • Suitable for most gutter types
  • Compatible with K-style gutters
  • Steel construction with powder coating
  • Installation doesn’t require screws
  • Custom sizes available
  • Prevents most debris from entering


  • Hard to install around brackets
  • Tough to remove
  • Instructions not included
  • Certain gutters may require trimming
  • Not suitable for snowy conditions

4. A-M Gutter Guard Aluminum Gutter Guard 5″

  • Type: Screen
  • Material: ‎Aluminum
  • Shape: Rectangular
  • Installation Method: Screws in
  • Total Pieces: 51
  • Weight: ‎25.2 pounds
  • Warranty: Lifetime
815Ud8TfGIL. AC SL1500

A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard Reviews

These A-M aluminum gutter guards are compatible with hidden hangars, but you can also use them with K-style hangars.

You can choose between lengths of 23, 50, 100, and 200 feet. Additionally, this product is available in these four lengths for 6-inch gutters, making it perfect for those on a budget.

The durable construction and 380 holes per linear foot of this guard make it suitable for heavy rains. It is made of high-quality aluminum that is corrosion-resistant.

The gutter fits snugly within the gutter top once installed and is virtually invisible, so you will not detract from the roof’s aesthetics. The installation may affect the roof warranty if not done carefully.

This product is easy to cut and install. It lets water flow and collects debris well. The only problem is that it does not include self-tapping screws like all other fastener systems. But the good news is, the company guarantees the durability of its guards for a lifetime.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for metal roofs


  • Patented design
  • virtually invisible from the ground
  • Reinforcement ridges for durability
  • Easy to install on new and existing hangers
  • Suitable for residential and industrial use
  • Manufactured in the USA


  • Larger debris may clog
  • Screws are not included
  • Designed for hidden hangers

5. E-Z-GUTTER GUARD EZ-Shield-10 Gutter Guard

  • Type: Screen
  • Material: ‎Aluminum
  • Shape: Linear Curve
  • Installation Method: Snap-in
  • Total Pieces: 1
  • Weight: ‎5.85 pounds
  • Warranty: Lifetime
71FNuAz5wYL. AC SL1500

E-Z Gutter Guard Reviews

Among the leading-notch gutter guards available today, the E-Z Gutter Guard is recognized as easy to install and long-lasting. It is highly durable and completely corrosion-proof, built from premium quality aluminum.

For almost 40 years, E-Z has manufactured and sold gutter guards. It has worked hard over the years to become one of the most respected brands in the industry.

This gutter guard covers your entire gutter system. As a result, there is no debris or leaves that can clog or overflow the gutter.

Since this gutter guard system is useful in extreme weather, no plastic is used in it. Paint and UV protection make aluminum durable and long-lasting. Indoors and outdoors, it is equally effective.

It is incredibly easy to install. These gutter guards are tension-engineered. It will snap on the gutter without drilling or screws because of its unique construction and design.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for oak trees


  • Easy to set up and take down
  • Ideal for rainy climates
  • Integrated tension system provides a secure fit
  • Made from aluminum for durability and corrosion resistance
  • Compatible with all types of hangars
  • Designed to filter all types of debris
  • Waterproof and UV resistant
  • No voiding of warranties
  • Designed and made in the United States


  • Incompatible with plastic gutters
  • Can clog with larger debris
  • Does not include screw

6. Gutter Cups Gutter Guards

  • Type: Gutter Cups
  • Material: ‎Polymer
  • Shape: Round Long
  • Installation Method: Lock-In
  • Total Pieces: 20
  • Weight: 4.99 pounds
  • Suitable for use in any weather condition

Gutter Cups Gutter Guards Reviews

Some people may not buy gutter guards because they aren’t DIY experts. To install a gutter guard, some people prefer using a ladder to drill and screws. In this situation, Gutter Cups Gutter Guards are the perfect solution, as they require no tools or clips to install, and they are adjustable to fit any size gutter.

There are multiple protective barriers with a perforated outer shell. In order to withstand severe debris and rain conditions, it was specifically designed and scientifically tested.

It removes debris, leaves, and other obstacles that threaten to clog your gutter. So the water flows easily through your spout, with no issues at all. This reduces water damage to the foundation, roof, and walls.

This is a unique system that is not available anywhere else. DIY gutter blockages are history when it’s on your gutters.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for cold climates


  • Affordable price
  • There are no tools or clips needed
  • Suitable for most residential gutters
  • Durable and flexible
  • They can be cut to your specifications
  • Multi-layer protection
  • Perforated outer shell
  • UV protection
  • Made of polymer
  • Installation is tool-free


  • Pine needles can clog them

7. Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard

  • Type: Downspout Gutter Guard
  • Material: ‎‎Plastic
  • Shape: Oval Triangle
  • Installation Method: Lock-in
  • Total Pieces: 4
  • Weight: ‎4 ounces
  • All sides of the guard drain water
61iS7K2JHKL. AC SL1000

Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard Review

When you use the Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard, you will get superior clog protection. The wedge design of the gutters allows the leaves to roll out and dry off.

Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard is more convenient to install compared to other filters and strainers. Most gutter downspouts will work with a 2×3 and 5-inch gutter downspout. Assembly takes minutes without the use of tools. Wedge connectors are included in the package.

The guard has an angle that allows water to flow through the top, bottom, and both ends. These features are lacking in other guards and covers. It is one of the best gutter downspout guards on the market currently.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for leaves


  • Installation is simple and requires no tools
  • Prevent clogging of downspouts
  • Screens keep smaller debris out of your downspouts
  • A wedge-shaped downspout keeps leaves from blocking it
  • More affordable than most gutter guards
  • Works with most standard downspouts
  • Manufactured in the USA


  • Still have to clean your gutters regularly
  • Mosquitoes are attracted to it
  • Structure is weak and easily broken
  • Only keeps leaves out of gutters, not debris

8. Thermwell Frost King VX620 6″x20′ Plastic Guard

  • Type: Mesh Gutter
  • Material: ‎‎Plastic
  • Shape: Linear
  • Installation Method: Not uniform
  • Total Pieces: 1
  • Weight: 0.48 ounces
  • Easily cut and shaped to suit requirements
81mOKAYtefL. AC SL1500

Frost King Gutter Guard Reviews

Thermwell’s Frost King gutter cover is a plastic alternative for those who do not want to invest in stainless steel. This screen gutter guard can be cut to fit with scissors, and it comes in a 6-inch by 20-foot roll.

It can be easily installed without screws, tacks, nails, or any other fasteners, and the plastic shield won’t rust or corrode. Since the material can resist extreme temperature changes, it safeguards your gutters all year.

The screen was easy to cut while we were on the ground, and the lightweight plastic was no problem to carry up a ladder. However, because this gutter guard uses no hardware, it can be a bit finicky to install correctly.

Throughout the year, this long-lasting design keeps your gutters free of debris from trees and winds.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for maple seeds


  • Quick and easy installation
  • Does not rust or corrode
  • Durable materials for rough weather
  • Comes at a very reasonable price
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Suitable for gutters of varying sizes


  • Installation is a bit tricky
  • The size isn’t universal
  • Weak construction may impair the durability

9. Massca Gutter Balloon Guard Filter

  • Type: Gutter Balloon Guard Filter
  • Material: ‎‎Aluminum
  • Shape: Circle
  • Installation Method: Push-in
  • Total Pieces: 4
  • Weight: ‎8 ounces
  • Warranty: 30-day refund
71z j BlHrL. AC SL1000

Massca Balloon Guard Filter Review

The Massca Gutter Balloon Guard Filter prevents unwanted materials like tree leaves from entering your downpipes. In the event of a heavy rainstorm, you won’t have to climb up onto your roof to clean. Its purpose is to keep water moving away from your home.

Massca’s downpipe leaf guards are easy to install. As such, you do not need to hire a professional or expert – you can simply shove the pieces into place.

It is also weatherproof, noncorrosive, and waterproof. Thus, this product will last for decades regardless of the weather. You will not have to climb up again to install them.

You can return it for a full refund if it isn’t waterproof and weatherproof. To get the ultimate gutter cleaning solution, you have to buy both gutter guards and balloon filters.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for copper gutters


  • Easy to shape and cut to fit
  • No rust or corrosion
  • Made of durable materials
  • Cost-effective
  • Lightweight and compact
  • Ideal for gutters of varying sizes
  • No tools are required to install
  • Extremely durable design for rough weather
  • Adapts to most downpipes


  • Gutter clogs rather than downpipes
  • Hard to lock into the spout
  • Leaves and small sticks can get stuck

10. GutterBrush Gutter Guard

  • Type: Gutter Brush
  • Material: ‎‎Stainless Steel & ‎Polypropylene Bristles
  • Shape: Rectangular
  • Installation Method: Push-in
  • Total Pieces: 4
  • Weight: ‎4.5 ounces
  • Fits universally
A1okiSWe8yL. AC SL1500

Gutterbrush Gutter Guard Reviews

This gutter guard is compatible with both fascia-mounted and shingle-mounted brackets, making it the most universal of the gutter guards. A cylinder-shaped wire core and nylon bristles are the key components of this system. They allow maximum water flow as well as keep debris out.

This gutter guard is made up of about five inches of UV-resistant polypropylene bristles that allow it to fit comfortably onto standard-size gutters (5 inches in diameter).

The gutter guards are easy to install and come in a variety of lengths. Press down gently on the guard so that it sits at the bottom of the gutter. Leaves, sticks, or other large debris will not clog the drainage system because of the bristles.

Keep in mind that brushes cannot keep out smaller debris or insects. Still, they will prevent clogging to a certain extent. They are also much more affordable than other options.

Editorial Verdict: best gutter guards for fir needles


  • Very easy to install
  • Flows plenty of water
  • Protects your gutters from animals
  • Keep ice dams from forming in the winter
  • Fits any 5-inch gutter
  • Allows rainwater to flow freely


  • Eventually clogs
  • Needs periodically cleaned
  • Even small debris can get into your gutters

Buyer’s Guide For Best Gutter Guards

Apart from considering which gutter guard is best for your home, there are a few more things to consider.

You must first identify your exact needs and budget. After that, you have to decide whether you will install the gutter guard yourself or hire a professional to do it. If money is not an issue, hire a professional. In these best gutter guards consumer reports you will find the info that you need.

1. Choose The Gutter Guard Type And Material

Homeowners typically select materials based on their budgets and gutter protection needs. However, certain materials may need to match an existing gutter system.

Stainless steel is often used for micromesh, screen, and reverse-curve gutter guards. It is typically expensive but durable. Stainless steel prevents rusting and corrosion which causes the gutter guards to expand, warp and crack under extreme temperatures.

Rust and corrosion are not an issue for copper screens and micro mesh gutter guards. Copper gutter guards are typically more durable (and more expensive) than any other type, and they are also harder to find since only a few manufacturers produce them. In this article, you can find the best gutter guards for copper gutters.

Micromesh and gutter screens are made of aluminum because it is lightweight and affordable. You can use them if there are no overhanging branches because there is less chance for branches and twigs to penetrate them.

Reverse-curve and brush guards are frequently made from plastic materials. However, brush guards are usually made of stainless steel or aluminum, while brush bristles are usually polypropylene. Inexpensive and non-corrosive, plastic is prone to swelling and cracking.

All foam gutter guards are made of foam. Water can filter through the foam, while debris is prevented from falling into the gutter. Foam is a durable, inexpensive material, but it is prone to mold growth.

In general, homeowners select materials based on their durability and how well the material holds up to the natural elements in their area.

What is the best gutter material?

  • The best gutter material is seamless aluminum gutters.
  • Aluminum gutters look great and won’t rust for years.
  • Copper is another option, but it is more expensive and lasts longer.
  • Vinyl is the cheapest option.

2. Analyze The Weather Condition Of The Location

Don’t overlook the weather conditions of the location where your house is located. If your property experiences extreme weather conditions, like heavy snowfall and heavy rain, you should invest in a high-quality, expensive gutter guard.

The type of guard you choose is the next factor to consider. Geographic location, local climate, foliage surrounding the home, wind speed, amount of rainfall annually, storm frequency, and maintenance frequency are all factors to consider.

3. Nature Of Debris

The type of debris can be a deciding factor. Before purchasing a gutter guard, you should think about the kind of debris your guttering system may encounter.

The gutter guards that have large holes are ideal if debris is big, like leaves and twigs. Alternatively, it would be best to consider a foam gutter guard that doesn’t allow physical debris to enter the gutter.

4. Compatibility

A typical spouting space is three, four, five, or six inches. Your home needs a gutter system that fits it.

To protect and maintain your property, you should have gutter guards installed. If you choose a gutter guard that clogs easily, you can damage your property’s foundation. Ultimately, this can result in greater damage.

Before determining your exact needs, take into account your location, the weather in your area, and what kind of debris you want to prevent from entering your gutters.

5. Size

To determine what size gutter guard is needed, you must climb up on a ladder to measure the width of the gutter. To determine the size of gutter guards and the number of guards required to protect a gutter system, it is also necessary to measure the length of each gutter.

The length of most gutter guards varies from 3 to 8 feet. The most common size for gutters is 5 inches, but other sizes are available as well: 4 inches, 5 inches, and 6 inches.

Gutter sizes exceeding 8 inches are rare. As a result, homeowners need to find a company that provides customized solutions to cover such gutters.

6. Visibility

It is crucial to find a gutter guard that matches the house or blends in with the existing aesthetic since gutter guards can be seen from the side and the top. Micro-mesh, screen, and reverse-curve gutter guards are more visible from the ground than foam and brush gutter guards because they sit in the gutter altogether.

White, black, and silver are the three standard colors of guards. Depending on the product, users can find guards in different colors, matching their gutters. It’s also good to match gutter guards with the roof color to achieve a cohesive and appealing look.

7. Product Warranty

Buyers should also pick gutter guards that offer a warranty to be covered if the gutter guards are defective or poorly manufactured.

A gutter guard’s durability depends mainly on its material. Aluminum or steel gutter guards are the most durable and likely to last the longest. The least durable gutter guards are plastic, vinyl, and foam, which are easily damaged by harsh weather and intense sunlight.

Gutter guards typically come with 5 to 50-year warranties. It is rare for brush and foam guards to come with a warranty because they are designed to provide a reprieve.

8. Cost

In general, when comparing guards of the same type and material, the cheaper guard usually fails before its more expensive counterpart.

So, saving money by buying cheap gutter guards may end up costing more in the long run. Expensive products aren’t always better.

9. Company Reputation

When a company offers a warranty, its reputation might be important to consider. In the event of a warranty claim, a reputable company will go the extra mile to replace broken gutter guards.

Moreover, reputable companies offer better, more reliable products, which is how they develop their reputation.

10. Professional vs. DIY Installation

Select gutter guards that are easy to install. Design can also be matched to gutter sizes and clipped around the edges to secure it to the gutter.

Installation of a roof above the first floor requires a professional. With one-story houses, the work is relatively straightforward and safe, and only basic tools are required.

In general, with the right ladder and some experience working at height, you should be able to install gutter guards on a two-story house as long as safety precautions are followed. To prevent serious injuries, always go up a ladder with a spotter and ensure a fall safety system.

Types Of Gutter Guards Explained

here’s a table comparing the top 5 differences between different types of gutter guards:

FeatureMesh Screen Reverse CurveFoam Brush Gutter
MaterialMetal or plastic meshMetal or plastic screenMetal or plastic with reverse curvePolyurethane foamBristles or polypropylene brush
InstallationClips onto the front lip of the gutter or slides under the shinglesClips onto the front lip of the gutter or screws into the gutter and fascia boardInstalled with the shingles and attaches to the front lip of the gutterInserts into the gutter and conforms to the shapeInserts into the gutter and conforms to the shape
EffectivenessGood for keeping out larger debris like leaves and twigsGood for keeping out larger debris like leaves and twigsRedirects rainwater and keeps out debris, but may still allow smaller debris throughGood for keeping out larger debris like leaves and twigsGood for keeping out larger debris like leaves and twigs
MaintenanceEasy to clean with a brush or hoseEasy to clean with a brush or hoseMay require periodic cleaning to prevent small debris buildupMay require periodic cleaning to prevent buildup of debris and dirtMay require periodic cleaning to prevent buildup of debris and dirt
CostModerately pricedModerately pricedMore expensive than mesh and screen guardsModerately pricedModerately priced

1. Screen

A wire or plastic screen prevents leaves from entering gutters. Sometimes, large holes with a comprehensive wire mesh are used instead of punching holes in sheets of material.

These are available in two main styles: hinged and flat.

Hinged guards have curved edges that allow debris to slide down and off the top.

Flat guards cover the top of the gutter with a flat panel. It is commonly installed underneath the roof shingles, making it more durable but less easy to access.

On a ladder, lift the bottom row of roof shingles and slide the gutter screen underneath the shingles, so the shingles hold the screen in place. A screen gutter guard is easy to install without tools, and it is inexpensive.

High winds or falling branches can dislodge gutter screens since they are not screwed down. Also, certain roof warranties are voided when the lower row of roofing shingles is pried off to install gutter guards.

This type of gutter guard has large holes, which makes it easy for small debris and insects to enter. This style is better suited to areas where leaves and sticks are the primary concern, rather than needles, dust, and fine debris.

On the other hand, because gutter guards have large holes, homeowners can clean them well with a high-pressure hose.

2. Micro Mesh

Most meshes are made from nylon, aluminum, or stainless steel. Water passes through the fine mesh gutter screen, while even the smallest debris is blocked.

Micro mesh gutter guards come in two types: One kind of mesh guard sits flat on top of the gutter, while the other uses gravity to draw debris down. Metal micro-mesh is fairly durable and can withstand extreme weather conditions.

The guard can be installed by slipping it under the first row of roof shingles, snapping it onto the gutter, or attaching it to the fascia (vertical strip just above the gutter).

Algae or mold can grow on fine-mesh screens in extremely wet environments. Some waterdrops may remain stuck in the mesh gaps due to the small gaps depending on the surface tension. As the temperature rises or the rain stops, the water evaporates. Hence, this is not an issue.

Though, it takes months to develop, so regular cleaning prevents this problem. A warranty protects the homeowner against premature wear and tear.

Sometimes you will need to use a hose sprayer and scrub brush to clean the ultrafine debris out of the mesh holes.

3. Reverse Curve

A reverse-curve gutter guard (or surface tension gutter guard) is made from lightweight metals or plastics. After flowing over the top of the gutter, the water takes a downhill curve, and debris and leaves fall directly to the ground below. It prevents leaves and debris from blocking gutters even in yards with many trees.

Compared to mesh and screens, reverse-curve gutter guards are more expensive. Since it must be properly attached to the roof fascia, it is less DIY friendly. Incorrect installation can lead to water running over the edge.

They appear as full gutter covers from the ground because they are installed over the existing guttering. Make sure that the product you choose matches the aesthetics and color scheme of your home.

The openings of gutter guards can become soiled with oil and sediment. When the opening becomes dirty, water cannot cling to the surface to guide it in, so it runs off the top of the guard. At the same time, heavy rain can cause the water to move too quickly and pass over the gutter opening.

The longevity of reverse curve gutter guards reduces the frequency of gutter cleaning, although all types require occasional maintenance.

4. Brush

The brush-style gutter guard looks a lot like a pipe cleaner. In addition to keeping debris out, it lets water pass through. There is a thick metal core made from metal wire, about one to three feet long, and it is covered with polypropylene bristles.

Just cut it to the proper length and place it in the gutter. No screws, bolts, or connections are required and the flexible wire core can be bent around corners, allowing to fit around corners of gutters. With their easy installation and low price, brush-style gutter guards are a popular DIY option.

They may require more cleaning than other guards since they tend to catch debris in their bristles.

In addition to being easy to clean, they can easily be taken out, sprayed with a hose, and replaced with little effort.

5. Foam

Triangular blocks of foam are used as rain gutter guards to block debris from entering and let water pass through easily. Three flat sides are arranged in the gutter: one to the back, one to the top, and one diagonally.

Typically, these guards don’t require nails or screws to stay in place, so there is less risk of damage or leaks. Typically, small sections are sold that easily fit into gutter systems. You can also cut them into angles to fit corner sections. Foam gutter guards are installed inside the rain gutters and are not visible outside.

The problem with these products is that they might not work well in heavy rainfall areas. The foam may quickly become saturated, causing the gutters to overflow.

They also do not keep out insects or rodents. In contrast to metal guards, foam guards are less durable. Additionally, oil and moisture cling to foam, which can cause mold and fungus to grow in gutters.

How To Install Gutter Guards

1. Clean And Repair Your Gutters Before Installing

You should clean and maintain your gutters before installing a gutter guard. You can use a garden hose to rinse the gutters and ensure they are snugly attached to the fascia.

Also, ensure that any bends or dents are straightened so the guard will fit. Lastly, dry the gutters before applying the sealant.

2. How To Measure For Gutter Guards

Measure the gutter length before purchasing gutter guards. The length of gutter guards varies from three to four feet, and some are sold by linear foot. If you know the right length and width, you will save money and avoid waste.

  • You should first purchase one panel of gutter guards to ensure the style fits appropriately on your gutters.
  • To determine how long your gutters should be, measure the length of your house’s exterior walls.
  • Divide the total distance by the length of each gutter guard – for instance, you’ll need around 50 gutter guards to cover 150 feet of gutters if each panel is 3 feet long.

3. How To Attach Gutter Guards

a) Screw / Bolt-On: Screws and bolts are the most secure way to attach gutters to existing structures. A gutter guard built from aluminum or steel will be less likely to break when snow, ice, or animals crawl across it.

The installation of screw-in gutter guards is also more complicated than snap-in models or guards that rest within the gutters. As a result, professional installation is recommended. Incorrect installation can damage gutters and guards.

b) Hinge: Gutter guards feature hinges that attach to gutters or fascia via clips or screws. You can clean them easily by rotating the hinge around.

Installation is not difficult since they clip into place. Hinge guards are usually made of aluminum, vinyl, or steel, and can be screened or mesh-style.

c) Snap-On / Lock-In: You can snap in micromesh guards and screens to gutters. To fit properly, the guard must match the guard’s size and type. The homeowner can usually attach snap-on guards by themselves without a professional’s help.

But this method is not the most secure. Animals, heavy debris, and wind can cause these gutters to fall off. For a more secure attachment, use screws or small bolts.

d) Resting (In-Gutter): You can also cover gutters from the inside instead of the top. Installing them is easy, but maintaining them can be a hassle. This attachment method is used by most foam and brush gutter guards and screen-style gutter guards.

e) Under-Shingle: When attached to gutters, they provide excellent gutter protection. Some mesh and screen guards use this attachment technique; however, it is always used with surface-tension gutter guards.

This technique is not recommended for gutter guards for several reasons.

4. Follow The Instructions Carefully

If you don’t follow the manufacturers’ instructions when installing the gutter guard, you may lose your warranty coverage.

Also, if the guards aren’t installed correctly, the gutters may overflow. In windy areas, you should invest in the guard fastener. Follow the instructions included in the materials.

5. Conduct Regular Inspections

Even with gutter guards, you should still clean your gutters twice a year. The guards may prevent some debris from entering your gutters, but some will still make their way through.

Keep your guards in good condition by checking them on a regular basis.

How Much Do Gutter Guards Cost To Install?

Depending on the type of gutter guard and how difficult the installation is, the cost of professional installation for a typical home with 200 feet of gutters can range between $300 and $2,000 on average.

Type of Guard & Cost (per foot):

  • Screen: $0.50–$5
  • Micro-Mesh: $1.50–$10
  • Reverse Curve: $5–$10
  • Brush: $2–$4
  • Foam: $2–$3

Based on the material per square foot cost:

  • Plastic screen guards: 20 to 40 cents
  • Aluminum gutter guard: 50 cents to 1.25 dollars
  • Steel screen gutter guard: 1.50 to 3 dollars
  • Foam gutter guard: 2 to 3.25 dollars
  • Micromesh steel guard: 2.25 dollars to 4 dollars
  • Brush gutter guard: 3.15 to 4.25 dollars
  • Solid surface gutter guard: 3.5 to 6.25 dollars

Are Gutter Guards A Waste Of Money?

In one word the answer is a big NO.

Gutters have many advantages if you choose the right one, install it properly, and maintain it when needed. Then it will protect your gutter for at least a decade. Here are some advantages of gutter guards:

a) Reduction Of Debris In Gutters: The gutter guard prevents leaves, pine cones, pine needles, twigs, sand, and gravel from entering the rain gutter system.

b) Insect And Rodent Prevention: Small rodents find nesting materials such as leaves, pine needles, and pinecones attractive. Without a cover, critters can easily enter gutters and settle in. Mosquitoes breed in clogged drains. By installing gutter guards, you can prevent debris from entering the gutter system, eliminate water pooling, and block insects and animals.

c) Protect Your Home From Fires: Having gutter guards can help protect your home from fire hazards, especially in places with a large amount of dry brush and high winds. As leaves, pine needles, and twigs accumulate and dry in the gutters, they create the perfect kindling for an ember to ignite.

In order to minimize this risk, noncombustible gutter guards prevent debris from piling up.

d) Requires Less Maintenance: Gutters guards prevent debris from entering them, so homeowners spend less time and energy cleaning them.

Most gutter guard companies claim that their products reduce maintenance by up to 50%. It is necessary to periodically clean the gutters or hire someone to do it, but much less often than if they were uncovered.

e) Preventing Ice And Cracks Due To Cold Weather: In cold climates, frozen ice can cause gutter guards to sag, warp, crack, or even separate from the fascia entirely.

Gutter guards prevent debris from entering gutters and build dams within them, thus reducing ice formation. Additionally, gutter guards can provide extra strength to the gutter system, allowing it to carry ice away if it accumulates in the gutters.

f) Protection Against Rust And Corrosion: Rust and mold can form within the gutter system due to water and wet leaves. If a gutter system is rusted, it can develop cracks and holes, which allow water to seep in. In addition to preventing the accumulation of water and moisture on gutters, gutter guards reduce the risk of rust and corrosion.

Read for more information: Are Gutter Guards A Waste Of Money?

Downside Of Gutter Guards

1) Repairs And Maintenance: Though gutter guards decrease the frequency of gutter cleaning, they do not eliminate it. Depending on where the house is located and how much debris forms around the gutters, gutter guards may still need cleaning twice a year.

2) Installing Gutter Guards: The process of installing gutter guards can range from simple to complex installations, even requiring professional assistance.

However, larger roofs or multi-story homes may require more time and effort to install. Whatever the case may be, gutter guards require some sort of installation, and this will incur a cost – time, energy, or money.

3) Initial Investment: The homeowner will undoubtedly have to spend money on the purchase and installation of gutter guards. Gutter guards can be as cheap as $1 per foot, depending on the type and brand.

On the other hand, quality and price are directly related; higher-quality gutter guards are more expensive.

4) Replacement And Durability: The gutters guards don’t last forever, so eventually they will need to be replaced. At some point, the homeowner must buy and install new gutter guards.

Gutter guards can last longer if the homeowner purchases good-quality guards and maintains them regularly. Certain companies also offer lifetime guarantees.

Gutter Failures: The Reasons Why

Most people don’t understand the importance of gutter cleaning, and they don’t necessarily bother to do it.

You can hire professionals to maintain your gutters and extend their lifespan. There are several important factors that cause gutters to fail.

  • Neglect: The most common cause of failure is neglect. The accumulation of leaves in the gutter or large amounts of dust or grime can also cause blockages. Pay attention and take action according to your surroundings.
  • Deterioration: Moisture can cause corrosion to the pipes of your gutter system. Steel pipes are most susceptible to corrosion. The steel gutters must be kept clean and free of debris of all kinds in order to prevent rusting and corrosion.
  • Gutter Spikes: Gutter spikes are often used to install gutter systems. However, the spikes may loosen over time. You may lose your entire gutter system if they are not regularly checked. You should always reinstall gutter spikes at intervals of one to five years.
  • Clogged Gutters: Clogged gutters cannot drain rainwater effectively. It is possible for debris to accumulate or roots and seeds from trees to grow into the path. You can avoid clogged drains by regularly inspecting your gutters.
  • Natural Strain: If the climate is not consistent and the temperature varies throughout the year. This could cause the drains to crack or weaken. The water in the gutters can freeze during cold snaps, exerting pressure on the walls and causing cracks or leaks.

How I Tested Gutter Guards

As an ex-professional gutter guard installer, finding the best products wasn’t too difficult. I skipped everything that I would not install in my home, a customer’s house, or my grandmother’s house.

The purpose of this best gutter guard reviews was to collect the top 10 gutter guards from major retailers worldwide and compare their types, materials, warranties, effectiveness, and whether or not they invalidate roof warranties.

Afterward, I gathered more information on each of the items on my list, including pros, cons, customer ratings, and complaints. This is how I selected them, and this is why they are worthy of your money and consideration.

Final Thoughts

Your home’s gutters must be kept clear of debris to prevent damage from water. The foundation of your house depends on good drainage; guarded gutters ensure adequate drainage around your house.

Additionally, cleaning gutters from a ladder is time-consuming and dangerous. You should definitely take advantage of any accessory that will reduce your gutter cleaning frequency.

This Top 10 best gutter guards consumer reports article provides all the information about what to look for when buying gutter guards that meets your needs. Don’t forget to protect your family and home with gutter guards. Install them today!

Related FAQs

Can you have gutters without downspouts?

Yes, you can have gutters without downspouts.

Downspouts are typically used to direct water away from the foundation of a building and onto the ground below. Gutters, on the other hand, are designed to collect rainwater and runoff.

By not having downspouts, you may be able to divert rainwater directly into the gutters, where it can flow naturally away from the building. However, if rainfall is excessive or gutters become clogged, water may overflow and damage the property below. In these cases, downspouts may be necessary to direct water away from the building properly.

Leave a Comment